The Posthuman Transition in 7 Phases – The Slippery Slope of 1998 Mariah Carey
The transition from biological to non-biological will come in phases, and it will be driven by our own human drives. I’ve written about this at length back in 2014 in…
There is a perverse belief that humans “deserve” to be free from work.
The ideal future painted by proponents of this belief is one where human happiness alone is the goal, and all the individual humans, dolphins, and puppy dogs get to live forever in harmony.
No obligations, no need to exert effort in order to eat and live.
Watch the full video essay here:
Two childish assumptions underlie this perspective:
(Both of these assumptions relate to seeing the world as a static “thing” [inaccurate] as opposed to a near-infinite set of emergent processes [accurate]. Read Process Realism for a deeper dive into this topic.)
We demean “work,” we pretend we are above it, but it is our greatest contribution, and in this article, I’ll argue that it is vastly more important than humanity itself.
Here I refer to “work” as:
“Any volitional effort which strives to add to the persistence and expansion of the greater living system that the volitional actor is placed within.”
Work is an attempt to contribute.
(Note that I used the term volitional, meaning an active effort. Obviously, many living things with no [or very limited] volition do contribute to the maintenance and expansion of the living process, but they can’t do anything about it. This essay is about what humans should do, a concern inaccessible to sea snails and peat moss. I don’t have certainty that humans have free will, but for the sake of this essay, I’ll presume we have some small amount of it.)
The need to work (to give, to contribute) in order to live is not an invention of capitalism, or a problem to be wiped away if we could only invent robot slaves.
The need to work in order to live is rightfully the way life and nature are structured in order to encourage the continued persistence and unfolding of the greater process of life. It is to be respected and taken into account in all that we do – it is not something to be “escaped.”
Today, the greater process of life implies not only human civilization and the entire biosphere, but also the emerging expansion of new non-biological forms of life.
In the remainder of this short article, I’ll lay out:
Let’s take a look at some of the categories of volitional activity that we might call “work.”
In addition to contributing in some way to the great system, “work” has another important trait:
It persists in the greater system by the choices of the agents that compose that system, not through force or coercion alone.
For example:
Most humans almost certainly don’t work to “contribute to the greater system,” just as most cells in your stomach don’t burn themselves in your bile out of some reverence for you as a human being.
Most people waiting tables or delivering plastic bags of Chinese food for DoorDash aren’t consciously aligning themselves with the needs and growth of civilization or life itself. But like the individual stomach cell, they are by necessity pulled into the greater system, and the greater emergent system beckons them to do as they must to contribute to it.
This contribution is noble.
Humanity is an ephemeral torch through which the great living flame is passing and expanding through, but the work (contributing to the greater system) is always there, will always be done. It was necessary before us, and it will be necessary after us.
Obviously, some businesses, governments, charities, and even some children (sorry) are net-detrimental to the greater system they are part of. We might think about online gambling businesses, or charities that exist to perpetuate the problems they claim to want to solve via grift (such as with homelessness in California), or research institutions that fraudulently prop up their results and poison the well of science for everyone else.
Fortunately, a reasonably large percentage of the time, these net-detrimental instances are buffered out of the greater process. This is made reasonably evident in the fact that the living process on Earth has become vastly and concisely richer and more powerful over the last 3.5 billion years, even in the face of massive asteroids and super volcanoes.
Sometimes, different types of “work” directly oppose one another, but are in fact part of the productive tension and creative force that ends up increasing the net power of the overall greater process of life.
Prey evolve to escape predators, parasites evolve to attack host species (oddly, parasites sometimes seem to strengthen the ecosystems they occupy), competing law firms or marketing agencies battle for the same client base, and opposing political parties generate (on occasion) new political perspectives or initiatives.
In the face of the great process, in the face of the fact that life itself is transforming at speeds vastly beyond the slow Darwinian processes that were dominant until now, we cannot possibly hope to preserve humanity-as-it-is.
We have the same two ultimate fates of all forms:
Torches are temporary – and ultimately serve the flame itself:

You don’t get to tell nature to coddle you for what you are.
You get the privilege to exist on the edge of death and be forced to constantly transform.
But there’s an unbelievable upside, the biggest upside imaginable:
You get the privilege to try your hardest to become whatever you must become to live in – and contribute to – the greater process of life that you’re part of.
Very soon, we’ll have to shed our humanity entirely to add to the stream of life.

In order for the blooming of the greater process to continue, we need people to find opportunities to give, to contribute, to work.
Augmenting our minds and bodies will be required to push the sciences’ forces, to solve problems, to drive value for the greater process – and this last furious effort is the gift we provide to the future. The baton is handed forward.
It is daunting to know that homo sapiens won’t be part of the future that results, that with enough time, all that we value and understand will be wholly recomposed and changed.
But the greater system depends on us to add to it, to imbue it with the powers, the tendencies, the creativity, and – at least for a short while – the values that will best promote its continued flourishing.
Wish not for freedom from work.
Wish instead for a longer window to contribute to the great process.
Wish for more work after AGI, not less.
The transition from biological to non-biological will come in phases, and it will be driven by our own human drives. I’ve written about this at length back in 2014 in…
Definition: The ‘transhuman transition’ describes the means and phases of change from the current state of homo sapiens (the human condition as we know it in 2019), to drastically altered…
Last week I posted an annotated version of my interview on Allan Saakyan’s Simulation Series show. Directly after the video went live I got personal messages (in some cases from…
The AI value alignment argument goes something like this: As artificial intelligence will continue to approach human-level intelligence Artificial intelligence will generally be driven by a reward function, by a…
I’ve been cajoled into watching Netflix’s Black Mirror, and a friend of mine recommended watching the San Junipero episode next. As I mentioned in my last Black Morror reflection, and I…
How can you keep artificial intelligence from taking over your job? In my latest TEDx talk, I explore what I’ve learned (from hundreds of interviews) about job security in the…